Should You Buy Properties with Cash or Mortgages?

People don’t want to get into debt because they think debt is a bad thing. They don’t want to have the risk of having a mortgage and debt that they must pay. You need to remember that when you get a mortgage, you’re using someone else’s money to buy a property. Your deposits can go further and your tenants who rent the property from you, are going to be more than covering the cost of the mortgage. If that weren’t the case, the bank wouldn’t lend you the money to buy the property in the first place.

Example

If you’re going to buy a property for £200,000 and you’re thinking about buying that cash. Let’s say you use that as an HMO, which is a very good strategy because it brings so much more rental income than a normal single-let property.

Costs Involved

As an HMO, you must pay some expenses. You’ve got to pay your insurance, you’ve got to pay for the utilities, the gas, the electricity. You’ve got to pay for the broadband internet, the TV license, the council tax. And let’s say if we take that off, let’s say it gives you a profit of £1,587 on that HMO, that would be almost £20,000 a year. £19,044 a year profit before tax, that’s not bad based on an investment of £200,000. The rental income is part of the profit you make, but one of the main benefits of investing in property is long-term capital growth. The reality is we live on an island in the UK, there is not enough accommodation. We have an increasing population. Over time, both the rents and property values go up. 

The government predicts we need 300,000 new homes every year. We are building less than 200,000 should we have this shortage of accommodation. According to this in about 10 years, historically property prices will double. That doesn’t happen every 10 years. It doesn’t happen in every area. It’s very much an average over time and around the country, I’ve certainly seen that having invested for almost three decades now, I’ve seen property prices skyrocket, the early ones I bought, and I’ve seen that kind of growth.

Cash vs Mortgage

Buying a property for cash, will give you almost £20,000 a year in profit after paying the expenses. Remember there’s no mortgage. And in 10 years, that £200,000 property might be worth £400,000. Meaning you’ve had a growth of £200,000, that’s a profit of a hundred percent on your initial investment. 

If you were to buy the same property, but instead of using cash, you’re going to use a mortgage. And let’s say you’ve been able to buy this property with a 25% deposit. So that’s £50,000 you put down as a deposit. The bank is going to lend you £150,000. Now, remember, you’re using someone else’s money to buy this property. You’re using the bank’s money. You’ve only put £50,000 in and the property has still gone up by £200,000 in 10 years time. So you’ve made a hundred percent profit on your money, but you’ve only put £50,000 in. So that’s a 200% return on your investment in 10 years time. 

Curious to hear more? Check out our property podcast where we post new content biweekly!

Join the UK’s Leading Property Investment Community

Want to stay ahead in the world of property investing? Get expert insights, tips, and updates delivered straight to your inbox. Be part of a thriving network of investors and take action towards your goals today!




£55K in 12 MONTHS – David McGinty’s R2R & R2RSA Property Success
£55K in 12 MONTHS – David McGinty’s R2R & R2RSA Property Success

Thinking about investing in a Serviced Accommodation in the UK or Rent to Rent Serviced Accommodation Deal? Interested in learning more about the Best Serviced Apartments you could put together in 2025? Growing up in a small mining village in Scotland, David spent 18...

Why Not Taking Action Is Stealing Your Money
Why Not Taking Action Is Stealing Your Money

Are you overthinking instead of doing? You’re not alone. Many aspiring property investors struggle with procrastination, getting stuck in the loop of planning and analysis without taking real steps forward. In this episode of the Property Magic Podcast, Simon Zutshi...

Is There Going to Be a Property Price Crash in 2025?
Is There Going to Be a Property Price Crash in 2025?

As someone who has been investing in property for over 30 years, I often get asked whether a crash is coming in the UK housing market. You might have seen headlines earlier this year reporting a 0.5% drop in property prices in March 2025, according to Halifax. While...

5 Steps to Secure Your Next Property Deal
5 Steps to Secure Your Next Property Deal

Far too many people overcomplicate property investing. They get bogged down in endless research, hesitations, and assumptions, and as a result, they miss out on great opportunities. The truth is, property investing doesn’t have to be complex. In fact, it can be boiled...

Build Wealth with 6 Properties: The Strategy That Pays You for Life
Build Wealth with 6 Properties: The Strategy That Pays You for Life

What if you could earn more from property than you ever could from your job—and keep getting paid, even after the work is done? That’s the concept I want to share with you today: Work once, get paid forever. It’s not a theory. It’s how I built my own property...

Repossessed Properties Are Not the Bargain You Think They Are
Repossessed Properties Are Not the Bargain You Think They Are

When you’re just starting out in property investing, the idea of picking up a repossessed property at a bargain price sounds like a smart move. After all, these are homes where the owner has fallen behind on mortgage payments and the lender is now looking to recover...

Does Property Investing Really Make You Financially Free?
Does Property Investing Really Make You Financially Free?

It's what I call the freedom illusion. Having invested in property for over 30 years, and spent the last 22 years helping people just like you become more successful property investors, I can tell you this: yes, for some people, property absolutely does set them free....

Ethical Property Investing – Are We Helping or Hurting Sellers?
Ethical Property Investing – Are We Helping or Hurting Sellers?

When I first started buying properties at a discount, I felt good about helping people. But I’ll be honest — part of me wondered what others might think. Why would anyone sell their home for less than it’s worth? It didn’t make sense at first. That’s a common...

Should You Buy Property in a Limited Company in 2025?
Should You Buy Property in a Limited Company in 2025?

One of the most common questions property investors ask in 2025 is whether it’s better to buy investment properties in their own name or through a limited company. It’s an important question, and the answer isn’t always straightforward—it depends on your personal...